The Infamous Shark Arm Case in Australia

Samuel Reason

In 1935, the infamous case of the shark arm started when a tiger shark in captivity vomited up a human arm. The tiger shark was in the Coogee Aquarium Baths on public display. After just a week it became very ill and vomited in front of a crowd. What came out was the forearm of a man with a very distinctive tattoo. Apparently before being captured the shark had eaten a smaller shark who had eaten the arm.

The investigation quickly became mainstream news because the tattoo indicated that the arm belonged to James “Jim” Smith. Smith was a former boxer and small-time criminal who had gone missing completely. It came out that Smith was also a police informer, so it was more than likely he had been murdered by a gang. The coroner confirmed the arm had been cut off by a knife and not by a shark bite.

Mysteriously the aquarium owner then killed the shark and got rid of it, which slowed down the police investigation. Many suspected the gangs had bribed him. However, inquiries led the police to William Holmes, who was a well-known smuggler and fraudster. He also owned a family boat-building business which was quite successful. It’s believed he had used Smith several times to work insurance scams where they would over insure boats and then sink the boats.

Nobody ever found the rest of Smith’s body, but it’s thought Holmes was involved. Because then the police were closing in, he attempted to commit suicide. But his .32 caliber pistol only stunned him, he even tried to get away from going to the hospital with a mad police chase around Sydney Harbour for several hours. In the end, Holmes agreed to cooperate with the police, but just a few days later he turned up dead after withdrawing £500 from his bank account.

A very strange tale of the Australian crime underbelly that has never really been solved. All because a shark vomited up an arm! Later a theory came out that Smith owed money to a major gangland figure known as Eddie Weyman, who was notorious for defrauding banks during the same period.

Next Article
  • The Worst Year Ever To Be Alive Was 536

    Ask any medieval historian and they will be quick to tell you that the year 536 was the worst to be alive in. You may have thought it would have been the Black Death of 1349 wiping out half of Europe or 1918 when the Spanish Flu killed nearly 100 million people but 536 was...

    Read More
  • A French Noblewoman Who Became a Ferocious Pirate Legend

    During the height of the Hundred Years War between England and France, one French noblewoman became feared throughout France for her ferocious never-ending appetite for revenge. Jeanne de Clisson with the help of the English outfitted three warships and caused havoc to any French ships crossing the English channel. Some may say privateer but at...

    Read More
  • The Caterpillar Eating Up Our Plastic Bag Problem

    Plastic bags are the closest actual thing we have to a real-life zombie apocalypse. You just can not kill a plastic bag no matter how hard you try. Even when scientists spent years perfecting new types of innovative bags made out of biodegradable plastics or shrimp shells(yes that is possible!), no one gave them the...

    Read More
  • The Day The Austrian Army Lost 10000 Soldiers To Friendly Fire

    Austria during 1787, or as they were known at the time the Hapsburg Empire, was a close ally of Russia. This was mostly to fight a common foe: The Ottoman Empire. The Turks were attempting to expand heavily into Europe and in 1788 there was fierce fighting in current day Romania, over who would control...

    Read More
  • The Greatest Submarine Escape Ever

    During World War II the clean and clear waters of the Mediterranean were a deadly zone for British submarines. They were easily spotted and bombed from the air by specialized submarine hunting planes. And due to the lower depths of the sea, they were easier to hunt with sonar, allowing gunships to drop lethal depth...

    Read More