The Thunderbird Photograph: Hoax, or a Real-Life Monster?

Chuck Banner | February 5th, 2017

Back in 1890, news of a strange sighting jarred the people of southeastern Arizona. A local newspaper, the Tombstone Epitaph, reported that two ranchers encountered an enormous, winged creature that they claimed looked like an alligator with wings. They were returning to Tombstone from a stint in the Huachaca Mountains when they came across the animal, which was reportedly visibly exhausted from some long flight, but flew a short ways when it saw the men. Armed and on horseback, the men began chasing the creature, firing at it until it was badly wounded and soon died. Amazingly, they said it measured about 92 feet in length, but was comparatively tiny in diameter at only 50 inches. Its head was an enormous 8 feet long, and each of its wings measured 78 feet in length, with no feathers or hair, just thick, rubbery skin. In short, the animal was massive – it was part bird, part alligator, and completely bewildering.

So did these men make up the story of the other-worldly beast for publicity? It’s entirely possible, since by 1890, Tombstone had turned into something of a ghost town after an earthquake flooded the lucrative silver mines which had provided the town’s only industry. It certainly could have benefitted from tourism that might have resulted from such a bizarre story. But no one seemed to make any effort to exploit the story to reel in tourists, and it was all but forgotten by the 1930s when author Horace Bell unearthed it as part of a book on Old West folklore. Then, in the 1960s, a magazine writer named Jack Pearl claimed that there had been a picture showing the ranchers having nailed the gigantic beast to a wall, and that it had appeared in the original article in the Tombstone Epitaph. In fact, several other people also claimed to have seem the photograph, but no one could locate any copies of it. And somehow, they all seemed to agree that it was indeed the type of photo described by Pearl.

By the 1990s, the search for the missing “Thunderbird Photograph” was in full swing; if so many reputable people claimed to have seen it, then it must exist somewhere. Finally, in 2015, a cryptozoology website, Cryptomundo, published several photos, supposing that one of them may be the lost Thunderbird Photo. But none of them even came close to matching Pearl’s description of the giant creature nailed to a wall (instead, one showed men standing behind a smaller bird-like creature on the ground, one showed men holding a large bird upside down, and the last showed Civil War soldiers and was clearly was not even from the right time period.) If seeing is believing, then we can assume that the Thunderbird sighting was nothing more than a hoax, due to the complete lack of convincing photo evidence. In all probability, the claims of having seen the photo of a creature nailed to a wall were some sort of psychological phenomenon, a “shared memory” of a photo that never actually existed. But, as some cryptozoology enthusiasts would be quick to point out, we also have no clear evidence that this creature didn’t exist, so we can’t be 100% certain that the men fabricated the story. Either way, for many, it’s fun to think about.

Next Article
  • In 1962 Maryland Declared Jousting Their Official State Sport

    One would have thought that jousting was reserved for a bygone time, the medieval ages. A time of knights, kings, and princesses; all galloping furiously on their noble steeds. Tipped from head to toy in ancient armor, jousting was a sport that was much loved for decades. Of course, as we entered the modern times...

    Read More
  • There Has Only Ever Been One Submarine VS Submarine Fight Ever!

    A famous film that dramatized underwater battle for the whole world to see is, of course, The Hunt For Red October, it portrayed a nerve-racking experience with crews deep under the ocean searching for their enemy with sonar. And though it is true that hunting undersea enemies is, of course,...

    Read More
  • Nuclear Pasta The Strongest Material In The Universe

    If you happen to be in the industry of creating the strongest materials in the universe, then you are in luck. We have the recipe and it only takes three easy steps: Find yourself one dying star and put into your favorite boiling pot, boil it until it goes supernova and explodes. Beware this could...

    Read More
  • Sometimes Little Galaxies Are Actually Cannibals

    Astronomers around the globe have long seen big galaxies like the Milkyway swallow up some of their little brothers and sisters. In fact, the sky is full of cannibals. They swallow up stars that are in their cosmic neighbors, and over time eat up whole galaxies. It seems only natural, that even in space, the...

    Read More
  • A 20 Min Extra Commute Is Worse On The Mind Than A Pay Cut

    A new study into what is seen as most negative when it comes to our daily work routines shows that being told you will need to commute an extra 20 mins to get home is just as bad as being informed about a pay cut. When it comes to job satisfaction it seems that commuting...

    Read More
  • The Oolichan Fish That Can Be Used As A Candle

    Oolichan fish is a type of fish that is so greasy it can actually be burnt and used as a candle. Hence it has the popular nickname the candlefish. The Oolichan is seen as a savior for many North Coast First Nations, the indigenous tribes of the Pacific northwest coast. This is because even though...

    Read More
  • Walt Disney’s Not So Happy Family

    You would think that growing up around animated series and seeing the creation of Disneyland first hand, would ensure that you would become a loving and happy family. In the case of Walt Disney’s grandchildren, this is just not the case, Michelle and her twin brother Brad Lund is far from being the happiest family...

    Read More