The Mysterious Death of Meriwether Lewis

Most people in the United States have heard of Meriwether Lewis, one half of the famed Lewis and Clark Expedition that claimed the Pacific Northwest for the U.S. and explored the newly purchased Louisiana Territory. Lewis was an extraordinary person by most accounts. During his life, he was a successful soldier and presidential aide. He was also a talented naturalist, who added to our knowledge of the natural world of the Americas during his travels. When he set out on his famous expedition, he was only 29 years old, and he was appointed governor of the Louisiana Territory at age 33 by President Jefferson.

Almost as intriguing as his life are the events surrounding Lewis’ death in October of 1809, at the early age of 35. He had been travelling towards Washington, D.C. with a small group of colleagues and a servant, when he fell ill with an attack of malaria, from which he suffered often suffered. After spending a few nights recovering at Fort Pickering in Memphis, he made it as far as Nashville before deciding to stop for the night at a lodging house owned by a Mrs. Grinder.

Mrs. Grinder later reported that Lewis had acted strangely during dinner that night. She later recounted that he would pace around the room, then sit back down and begin talking to himself. By the time he went to his cabin for the evening, Mrs. Grinder was quite wary of him, but she was afraid to say anything to him since she was alone there with her children.

Some time that night, she heard gunshots and the cries of Lewis begging for water. She claimed to be so frightened at this point that she did not dare go out to help him, though she watched him crawl back to his cabin through a small hole in her door.

The next morning, Mrs. Grinder decided to check on her guest. She found him in his cabin, wounded from gunshots to his torso and the side of his bead and with cuts all over his body, presumably from his razor. He died later that morning from his extensive injuries, complaining that it was taking him too long to die because he was so strong.

His death was quickly determined to be a suicide, due to his history of erratic behavior. Lewis had often suffered by what we might now call severe depression. He also reportedly had problems with debt and alcoholism, and he may have even used opium. He was said to be quite troubled during his journey, because he felt he had failed as governor of Louisiana. He also saw his great expedition as something of a failure, since he had failed to discover a Northwest Passage to the Pacific Ocean. The fact that he had written a will during his travels further solidified the conclusion that he had killed himself.

Most historians accept the verdict of suicide, but many conspiracy theorists question this conclusion. They point to the fact that Lewis, an expert marksman, would not have so terribly bungled the job of shooting himself. Since his money was missing at the time of his death, his servant or even Mrs. Grinder have been suspected of killing him in order to rob him. But other valuable items were left in his possession, which somewhat weakens this theory. However, Lewis’ servant killed himself shortly after the incident, after Lewis’s mother accused him of murdering her son. The Grinders also bought some expensive property a few years later, and no one knows where they obtained the money to do so.

There are also some complicated theories suggesting that Lewis may have been assassinated for political reasons by various rivals in government. All of these possibilities have their limitations, including suicide, unless you take into account Lewis’ regular bouts of malaria. Many people suffering from attacks of this disease show symptoms of dementia due to the severe fevers that accompany them. Lewis himself often reported in his journals that he was suffering from fever, and we know that he had been ill during this particular journey. His fevered confusion could explain the haphazard way he committed suicide, along with his terrible thirst that night.

Whether he was murdered or killed himself, Lewis’ death was a great loss for the United States. His adventures and advancement of scientific knowledge inspired many others naturalists and adventurers to continue his studies.

Lewis was buried near the Grinder’s property, and the state of Tennessee built a memorial to him nearby in 1848. It is composed of a broken column, symbolizing a life cut short.

Next Article
  • Let’s Nuke The Moon Just Because We Can

    Any guesses to who once said that? Yup, you guessed it… The United States once planned to shoot a nuclear bomb at the moon for the sole reason of “Because We Can!” The absolute ridiculous project was put into action during the 1950s by the U.S. Air Force and was...

    Read More
  • The Biggest Spread Of Plague Was Not Caused By Rats

    New studies have shown that rats have been unfairly accused of being the main culprit of causing the immense spread of plague during the time known as the Black Death. Initially, the rats were believed to have spread the plague so severely during 14th century Central Europe due to them...

    Read More
  • The First Medieval North American City

    Cahokia was a settlement that thrived during the years of A.D. 1050-1200, a city that held a population of 10000 to 20000 people and covered over six square miles. This made it bigger than even London at the time and numerous other European cities. It was located in Mississippi, close...

    Read More
  • Twenty-Two Years Of Poop Removed Surgically From One Man

    Remember that last time you could not go to the toilet? You just sat there in agony, with just nothing coming out? Or that constipated bloated sensation that never goes away, well now think that you have had that feeling for wait for it... 22 whole years. Impossible, right? Yes, one Chinese man has defied...

    Read More
  • Yes, There Was A Black Nazi

    Meet Hans Massaquoi, one of the very rare and few biracial Germans who were born and grew up during the Nazi regime. Though do not be mislead by the photo, he was not actually allowed to join the Nazi Party. This does not really make much sense when you remember...

    Read More
  • Marijuana Farms Are Killing Owls

    In California the great marijuana legalization growing revolution is having some dire consequences to the local ecosystem, notably, it seems to be killing Northern spotted owls! Unfortunately the profitable of the marijuana legalization vote in California has seen the rise of numerous unpermitted private grow sites. These grow sites are...

    Read More
  • Napoleon’s Biggest Loss Was Against A Horde Of Rabbits

    Napoleon Bonaparte, the famous French emperor who dominated European and even global affairs for over a decade from 1804 to 1814. Renown for being one of the greatest military commanders ever to rule, his campaigns and victories are still studied around the world today. He won the vast majority of his battles, which means his...

    Read More