The Lost Tribe That Wasn’t

In the 1970s, the Philippines were in trouble. Or, to be more accurate, their despotic leader, Ferdinand Marcos, was in trouble. He had mismanaged the finances of the country so badly that many Filipinos could not even afford the basic necessities of life. World opinion was starting to turn against him, and he desperately needed a distraction. Imagine his luck, then, when a previously uncontacted Stone Age tribe was suddenly discovered on the Philippine island of Mindanao.

The lost tribe, called the Tasaday, were discovered by a pal of Marcos’ named Manuel Elizalde, who was the Secretary for National Minorities under Marcos. Elizalde had supposedly been informed of the tribe’s existence by a hunter who had stumbled upon them in the forest. He immediately flew out to the jungles of Mindanao to meet the lost tribe and wasted no time turning them into a media sensation.

media.licdn.com

It didn’t take long for reporters, scholars, and celebrities to start arriving in the Philippines to meet the gentle Tasaday people for themselves. The supposedly cave-dwelling people who wore only loin cloths were the main subject of an issue of a 1972 National Geographic magazine, and a bestselling book was written about them. They were said to be such a peaceful people that they did not even have a word for “enemy.”

But trouble was brewing, and a major controversy came with it.

Elizalde tightly controlled access to the tribe. Soon after their discovery and the stir it caused, Marcos declared martial law. It suddenly became difficult to access the Tasaday. In 1976, Marcos completely prohibited anyone outside the government from visiting them.

When Marcos was eventually overthrown in 1986, a Swiss journalist named Oswald Iten decided to try to make contact with the forgotten Tasaday tribe once more. What he found uncovered one of the greatest hoaxes of the modern era.

When he located the tribe, they were living in regular huts, not caves. They were dressed in modern clothing, instead of the primitive loincloths they had previously worn. When Iten questioned them, they admitted that they had never lived in caves. Elizalde had forced them off their farms and made them live in the caves so they would be more convincing as a pre-contact Stone Age tribe. He promised them money and protection if they went along with the ruse for a period of time, but neither form of aid ever materialized.

In retrospect, many people now saw inconsistencies in the original Tasaday story. They did not understand how they had avoided contact with the modern world for thousands of years when they were only a few miles from a normal village. Many of their utensils looked as if they had been cut with steel knives, but they supposedly had never seen steel. Things just didn’t add up upon further inspection.

After Iten’s interview, the world decided they had been tricked by Marcos. Documentaries about the hoax were made, and the fake tribe was widely ridiculed.

The Tasaday tried to retract their statement that they were part of a hoax. They even won recognition for the government of Corazon Aquino as a Stone Age tribe in 1988. To this day, no one is sure what the whole truth is regarding the Tasaday, other than the fact that they were not truly a Paleolithic pre-contact tribe. A short documentary about them, which was made in 2009, showed them as they are now. They are simple farmers, who are poor and poorly educated. They never received any help from the government for their participation in the ruse.

Manuel Elizalde, the man who perpetrated the hoax, left the Philippines with millions of dollars that did not belong to him. He died in 1997 at age 60, having never been punished for his role in exploiting the Tasaday or stealing the money.

Next Article
ADVERTISEMENT
  • The South’s Most Haunted Plantation

    The plantations of the southern United States are full of terrible history because of their connection with the cruel institution of slavery. It should come as no surprise, then, that many of them are believed to be haunted because of the terrible things that happened on them. The Myrtles Plantation in St. Francisville, Louisiana may...

    Read More
  • Extinct Penguin Species Never Really Existed

    In 1983, scientists discovered four penguin bones in an archaeological site on Hunter Island in Tasmania. The 750-year-old bones were determined to belong to a previously unidentified species of penguin, which they then dubbed the Hunter Island penguin. As no living Hunter Island penguins existed, the species was declared extinct as soon as it was...

    Read More
  • The Scottish Head Hunter

    Jack Renton followed in the footsteps of many of his fellow Scotsmen when he decided to make his living from the sea. And, like a fair number of his fellow sailors, he found himself shanghaied in 1868 at the age of 20, meaning he was kidnapped and forced to work aboard someone else’s ship. Naturally,...

    Read More
  • Was Alexander the Great Killed by Poison Water?

    For centuries, historians believed that Alexander the Great, the Macedonian king and fearless military leader, died after one of his many all-night drinking parties. His drinking buddies reported that he cried out from a sudden, stabbing gut pain and took to his bed, from which he never got up again. He died twelve days later,...

    Read More
  • How a Tea Party Saved an American Regiment

    It was 1776, and Mary Lindley Murray found herself in an awkward position. This wealthy Quaker woman and wife of a wealthy merchant favored the American revolutionary cause. Her husband, however, was a known loyalist and supporter of the British. The Revolutionary War was going on all around her, and she was eventually faced with...

    Read More
  • Ancient Infant Ape Skull Sheds Light on Human Origins

    The lemon-sized skull of a baby ape was recently uncovered by scientists in northern Kenya. Though this at first sounds like an unremarkable find, the skull, which was buried under layers of volcanic ash, is at least 13 million years old. On top of this, researchers believe that it belongs to the earliest common ancestor...

    Read More
  • Was the Delphic Oracle “High”?

    Anyone who has read about or studied Greek history and mythology has heard of the Oracle of Delphi. The Oracle was a powerful priestess who spoke prophecies, supposedly after being filled by the spirit of the god Apollo. She supposedly delivered these prophecies while in some kind of trance. Historians and scientists have often wondered...

    Read More
  • Miracle Mike the Headless Chicken

    In September of 1945, Lloyd Olsen and his wife, Clara, a farming couple in Fruita, Colorado, were expecting company for dinner. Clara’s mother was coming for a visit, and chicken was on the menu. Knowing that his mother-in-law enjoyed chicken necks, Lloyd tried to leave as much neck as possible on the rooster he was...

    Read More