The Haunting Tale of Midnight Mary

Kamie Berry | October 28th, 2017

In Evergreen Cemetery, which sits in downtown New Haven, Connecticut, there is a grave marker that belongs to the grave of Mary E. Hart, who was born in 1824 and died in 1872. There is nothing remarkable about this grave, except for its strange inscription, which reads, “The people shall be troubled at midnight and pass away.” This quote, which is from the Old Testament Book of Job, would seem a curious one to place on a grave. At least it would be if one was not acquainted with the tale of Midnight Mary.

Mary Hart lived a rather ordinary life, though it was doomed to be short. She was living with an aunt in 1872 when she suddenly fell to the floor. She was unconscious, and no attempt to revive her met with any success. She was pronounced dead and was buried the next day in Evergreen Cemetery.

3.bp.blogspot.com

That might have been the end of the story, were it not for a strange dream her aunt had the night of the burial. In this dream, the aunt saw Mary in her coffin, screaming and trying to get out. The nightmare was so vivid that Mary’s aunt believed it to be a message that Mary was still alive. She went to the authorities and begged them to exhume her niece.

The authorities agreed to the exhumation, and what they found was the stuff of true nightmares. It seems that Mary wasn’t really dead when she was buried. Her fingernails and fingertips were shredded and bloodied, and it was evident she had tried desperately to scratch her way out of the coffin. But since she had lain in the ground for over 12 hours by this time, she had suffocated and was now truly dead.

Such tales of premature burial were unnervingly common in the Victorian era. Without the ability to determine brain death, some people who suffered heart attacks or strokes and who became unconscious were presumed dead. They might revive later, but they would already be underground at this point. This is what happened to Mary Hart.

Of course, such a macabre tale has inspired many a ghost story. Some say that the inscription on Mary’s gravestone is a warning that anyone who comes into the cemetery after midnight will die, being cursed by Mary, who is angry at the world for her untimely burial. Others tell tales of seeing a ghostly woman in Victorian clothing walking on the road near the cemetery if you happen to drive by at midnight. Still today, people will leave offerings of coins or candy on her gravestone to placate her angry spirit.

You can still see Mary’s gravestone today at the cemetery. It is located at the back of the graveyard, so you’ll have to walk a long way to reach it and to leave. Just be sure not to visit Evergreen Cemetery after midnight.

Next Article
  • A Sealed Garden That Was Last Watered 46 Years Ago

    One keen gardener was curious in 1960 and decided to plant a seed in a bottle which he promptly sealed up. David Latimer never thought he would be on to one of the first self-sustaining ecosystems, which has become an amazing case study for biologists around the world. When you break it down, this plant...

    Read More
  • Olympics Athletes Are Zapping Their Brain For Performance Increases

    A strange phenomenon is taking over the sports industry at an alarming pace, one that sees professional athletes zapping their brain in name of increasing their performance. The technology uses brain simulation with the goal of increasing everything an Olympic athlete needs to grab that gold medal. The basic explanation...

    Read More
  • The Sea Creature That Eats Its Own Brain

    There is one little creature that lives in tidal pools and over shallow ocean areas, that has a rather strange and fascinating characteristic: it eats its own brain. The sea squirt is a little undersea animal which is part of the tunicate family. Whenever poked or threatened, this small animal...

    Read More
  • Pokemon Go A Security Fear For The Pentagon

    If you happen to love Pokemon Go but work for the American government at the Pentagon, well that is just too bad. All employees are banned from playing Pokemon Go inside the Pentagon walls, due to its mapping features. Anyone working at the facility in Arlington, Virginia has been given...

    Read More
  • The Infamous Porthemmet Beach Hoax

    In some regions of the world no matter how much the local area survives off tourism, there is just a general distaste for tourists in general. All these strangers tramping around your Townsquare asking for directions, one of those places in Wales. With all the coastlines and beautiful beaches, locals can tend to get very...

    Read More
  • A Castaway Who Survived 14 Months At Sea

    One man defied all the odds and was able to survive lost at sea for over 14 months. This is no story of being washed up on an island and finding coconuts, this man just drifted around the ocean for months on end. He is called Jose Salvador Alvarenga and...

    Read More
  • The Romans Actually Invented The Swiss Army Knife

    When you think of the Swiss Army Knife you would have thought it was invented in Switzerland - and it was, unless you count Roman’s version as the first one. A spoon, a knife, a fork, and toothpick - all the tools you need to extract the meat out of the shells of seafood. This...

    Read More